Skip to Content

Interpretation Services: Benefits and Drawbacks

Basic Path

Learning Objective

Understand the importance of using professional interpretation services rather than untrained interpreters.

 

Introduction

Interpretation is the oral equivalent of translation. To ensure effective communication with patients, health professionals may need to use interpretation services in certain situations. There is no legislation in Canada governing the use of interpreters; each health facility manages this differently. It is important to recognize that the use of interpreters can impact the quality and safety of care and may also raise ethical considerations.

 

  • Professional interpretation services are sometimes essential for improving communication and support the effective use of health services, particularly for Canadians whose first language is neither French nor English.

    In contrast, using an untrained interpreter increases the risk of errors in transmitted information, including omissions, substitutions, alterations, and additions (Flores G, Laws MB, Mayo SJ et al., 2003).

    (Flores G, Laws MB, Mayo SJ et al. Errors in medical interpretation and their potential clinical consequences in pediatric encounters. Pediatrics. 2003;111(1):6-14. doi: 10.154 2/peds.111.1.6.)

     

    Risk of bias

    Using a close acquaintance as an interpreter can introduce bias, omissions, or alterations in the transmission of information.

     

    Impact on confidentiality

    Patients may feel very vulnerable sharing confidential information in the presence of a family member, community member, or another person acting as an interpreter who has not been trained for this role.

     

    Medical errors

    Poor translation of essential information can lead to diagnostic or treatment errors.

     

    To learn more about health care interpretation services, see the article “Using Interpreters in Health Care Settings” on the Caring for Kids New to Canada health site.

     

    Consulter les ressources

  • When direct access to services in the official language of one’s choice is not possible, using professional interpretation services is a reliable way to ensure the safe and high-quality delivery of health care.

    According to a study by Danielle de Moissac, accompanying interpreter services address a real need for people with complex health and support needs. However, relying on non-professional interpreters creates many challenges, potentially compromising care quality and risking patient safety.

     

    Consulter les ressources

  • Quiz

    Feedback :

    The correct answer is:

    b) False

    No legislation regulates the use of interpreters in Canada. Each health care facility has its own way of managing this matter.

    Feedback :

    The correct answer is:

    a) True

    It is important to recognize that the use of interpreters can impact the quality and safety of care and may also raise ethical considerations.